About Olde Florida Insurance

Proudly located in Fort Myers, Florida, Olde Florida Insurance is your trusted, local insurance agency – dedicated to serving the insurance needs of Southwest Florida individuals, families and businesses with over 50 years of experience.


Meet the team:

Lori Roth

Lori is a licensed insurance agent with 30 years of experience. A native of Fort Myers she takes pride in her attention to her clients needs and her focus on providing them with excellent customer service.

Gary Roth

Gary brings over 30 years of experience to the agency. As a licensed insurance professional, he has extensive knowledge of all lines of insurance. His primary focus is to provide his commercial clients with the best insurance products to protect their business exposures. Gary can do it all, including bonds, life and health insurance.

Pam Jones

With over 30 years of experience in the insurance industry, Pam works with our commercial lines to ensure the highest level of customer service and marketing

Kathy Buelow

Specializing in the needs of Condo Associations, Kathy brings over 25 years of experience to the team. 


Why choose an independent agent?

Florida homeowners have unique insurance needs. Our agents will take the time to find comprehensive coverage from our many homeowners insurance providers that fits you and your particular needs. At Olde Florida Insurance we are committed to proving insurance doesn't have to be frustrating, complicated nor an expensive process for the consumer- rather it allows us to build meaningful relationships with our clients, employees and partner insurance carriers.